Skip to main content

Should you reach out to an attorney or contact the insurance company first?

In the aftermath of a car accident, individuals often find themselves grappling with uncertainty about the appropriate course of action. The pivotal question arises: should one promptly contact their insurance provider to initiate a claim, or should they contemplate reaching out to a legal professional? The decision regarding whom to contact first can significantly impact the outcome of the post-accident process and the subsequent pursuit of compensation.

Car Accident

The decision to initiate contact with your insurance company prior to seeking legal counsel can entail certain inherent drawbacks and potential pitfalls. It is paramount to recognize that the insurance adjuster assigned to your case is not an advocate for your best interests; rather, their primary duty is to safeguard the insurance company’s profits by minimizing payouts.

One substantial disadvantage of making initial contact with the insurance company is the comprehensive questioning to which you will be subjected. These inquiries encompass details about the accident itself and the extent of your injuries, all of which are meticulously recorded. Any inadvertent misstatements or oversights during this process may be opportunistically exploited to deny or minimize the value of your claim.

Furthermore, engaging in discussions with the insurance company prior to seeking legal guidance may expose you to premature settlement offers. These offers may appear equitable on the surface, but they are typically presented before a comprehensive assessment of your damages has taken place. Without a thorough understanding of the full extent of your injuries and losses, you might be inclined to accept these offers prematurely. This decision, particularly when made on a recorded line, can complicate the pursuit of adequate compensation for unforeseen and long-term damages, such as ongoing medical expenses associated with prolonged injuries.

It’s also worth noting that when you engage with the insurance company before consulting an attorney, you might inadvertently provide them with a strategic advantage. Insurance adjusters often inquire about your injuries with the objective of streamlining the scheduling of medical appointments. These appointments are typically arranged with healthcare providers who have affiliations or contractual agreements with the insurance company. While the convenience of having the insurance company assist with appointment scheduling may seem appealing, it’s imperative to exercise caution regarding the healthcare providers who will be treating your car accident injuries.

In instances where the insurance company proactively contacts you prior to your consultation with an attorney, it is advisable to assert your preference for engaging with legal counsel first. If you opt to engage in a conversation with the insurance adjuster, it is essential to remain vigilant and mindful of the circumstances.

Key considerations during such interactions include:

1

Recording

All conversations with the insurance company are typically recorded, which underscores the importance of maintaining a cautious and measured approach.

2

Injuries

It is advisable not to discuss the full extent of your injuries during these initial conversations. Instead, focus on providing only essential and factual information.

3

Extraneous Details

Avoid volunteering excessive or superfluous details about the accident. Stick to the relevant facts and refrain from elaborating on peripheral aspects.

4

Fault

Do not admit or imply fault during your discussions with the insurance adjuster. Your statements can be used against you in future negotiations.

5

Assumptions

Avoid making assumptions about the circumstances or causes of the accident. Stick to facts and avoid speculations.

6

Settlement Offers

Do not hastily accept any settlement offers presented by the insurance company during these early discussions.

Once the conversation with the insurance company concludes, it is of paramount importance to expeditiously reach out to an attorney who can provide expert guidance throughout the ensuing legal process.

The rationale for prioritizing a consultation with an attorney before contacting the insurance company is grounded in multifaceted considerations. Immediately following a car accident, the primary number to dial is universally recognized as 9-1-1. Subsequently, your next point of contact should be with a legal professional.

Upon establishing communication with an attorney, you gain access to a valuable resource who can assist you in navigating the intricacies of filing an insurance claim. The advantage of involving an attorney from the inception of your case lies in having a dedicated advocate who possesses an intimate understanding of the legal landscape. This includes a nuanced awareness of what information should be disclosed and what should be withheld when addressing your injuries and the circumstances of the accident.

The safeguarding of attorney-client privilege is another compelling reason to consult with an attorney as your initial point of contact. This legal privilege ensures that all communications between you and your attorney are confidential. Consequently, you can freely and candidly discuss the details of your case, your injuries, and your concerns without fear of compromising the strength of your claim. This level of confidentiality can be instrumental in building a robust case.

Furthermore, the attorney-client relationship fosters an environment of trust and open communication. Your attorney, being intimately familiar with the particulars of your case, can provide you with tailored advice and guidance on how best to proceed. Their expertise extends to the negotiation process, which includes strategic positioning and the presentation of your case in the most compelling manner possible.

Another noteworthy advantage of reaching out to an attorney as your initial point of contact is the assurance that you are aligning yourself with a professional who is singularly committed to your best interests. Conversely, the insurance company’s primary allegiance is to safeguarding its financial bottom line, which may not necessarily be congruent with your pursuit of just compensation.

In conclusion, the sequence of actions taken following a car accident can profoundly impact the outcome of your case and your ability to secure fair compensation. While the instinct may be to immediately contact your insurance company, it is essential to recognize the potential drawbacks and pitfalls associated with this approach. The foremost recommendation is to prioritize a consultation with a qualified attorney as your initial step. This strategic decision provides you with the necessary legal guidance, safeguards your rights and interests, and ensures that you have an unwavering advocate committed to securing the compensation you deserve.